Guide · Withholding · 2026
Bonuses and overtime: why the withholding looks too high
A $10,000 bonus on a $60,000 salary, paid in the same check as December’s pay. The bonus leaves $3,008 behind — $2,243 of income tax and $765 of FICA — and that is 30% of it. The tax it actually adds to the year is $1,550. The $693 difference is not a rate. It is a prepayment computed by a payroll system that cannot see the rest of your year.
What the 22% actually is
Federal withholding on extra pay runs under two sets of rules, and the one your employer uses is a choice, not a law of nature.
Paid separately — a bonus check, or an amount separately stated on the stub — the employer may withhold a flat 22% of it, provided it withheld income tax from your regular wages this year or last. Above $1,000,000 of supplemental pay in a calendar year the rate becomes 37% and the choice disappears: that part is withheld at the top rate whatever your W-4 says.
Paid inside the regular check, with no separate statement of the amount, the employer must instead add the extra to the period’s wages, work out the withholding on that combined figure as if it were a normal paycheck, and subtract what it had already withheld. This is the aggregate procedure, and it is the path overtime usually takes, because overtime normally appears on the same check as the regular hours and is not stated apart from them.
Either way, 22% is not a tax on bonuses. It is the rate on taxable income between $50,400 and $105,700 — the bracket that runs from $66,500 of salary to $121,800 for a single filer. Below the first figure the flat rate takes more than the bonus will owe; above the second it takes less.
| Single filer | Bonus | Withheld at 22% | Tax the bonus adds | Settles as |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| $50,000 salary | $5,000 | $1,100 | $600 | $500 refund |
| $60,000 salary | $10,000 | $2,200 | $1,550 | $650 refund |
| $75,000 salary | $5,000 | $1,100 | $1,100 | exact |
| $120,000 salary | $10,000 | $2,200 | $2,364 | $164 due |
| $250,000 salary | $10,000 | $2,200 | $3,200 | $1,000 due |
Four of those five rows are wrong by a few hundred dollars, and none of them is a mistake. The flat rate is a single number asked to serve every bracket, and the bonus is settled against the real schedule when the return is filed.
The two methods differ by $43 here
The same $10,000 bonus, paid inside the December check instead of on its own, goes through the aggregate procedure. Monthly pay of $5,000 normally withholds $418. The December check of $15,000 is annualised to $180,000, the tax on that is worked out, divided by twelve, and withheld: $2,661. The bonus portion therefore carries $2,243, or 22.4%.
That is $43 more than the flat rate would have taken, and both are about $700 more than the bonus costs. The method matters far less than the fact that either one is estimating: a December paycheck cannot know what January to November already withheld, and it does not try.
What the check does show is a rate on the whole of it. This one withholds 17.7% against the 8.4% of a normal month, and the jump is what people notice. It is not a surcharge on the bonus; it is the average rate a $180,000 salary would face, applied for one pay period to a salary that will not be $180,000.
Why an overtime check looks worse than the tax
Overtime is legally supplemental pay, but the regulations let an employer treat it as regular wages instead, and when the hours simply sit on the same stub as everything else that is the path of least resistance. So the check is annualised — as if every check for the year looked like this one — and the whole of it is withheld at that annual figure’s average rate.
Take a $52,000 salary paid biweekly: $2,000 a check, $25 an hour, $156.15 withheld, or 7.8%. One week brings 30 hours of overtime at time and a half, $1,125 of extra pay. The check becomes $3,125, annualises to $81,250, and withholds $347.88 — 11.1% of the check.
| Biweekly check | Regular | With 30 hours of overtime |
|---|---|---|
| Gross | $2,000 | $3,125 |
| Annualised | $52,000 | $81,250 |
| Federal withheld | $156 | $348 |
| Rate on the check | 7.8% | 11.1% |
The overtime dollars themselves carry $191.73, which is 17.0% — and that is the number that looks punitive. The tax they actually add to the year is 12%, or $135, because the salary stays in the 12% bracket whether or not one week ran long. The $57 difference comes back at filing.
If the overtime runs all year, the annualised figure is right and there is nothing to reclaim. The distortion exists precisely because the method cannot tell a busy week from a busy year, and it errs upward in both directions: it withholds the average rate of a salary you may never earn.
The part that really is 7.65%, and does not come back
Income tax is the flexible layer. FICA is not. Social Security takes 6.2% of every dollar up to $184,500 of wages, Medicare takes 1.45% with no ceiling, and neither rate changes because the money arrived as a bonus. On the $10,000 bonus that is $765, withheld at the same moment and never refunded.
That is why the bonus check feels worse than the table says. The $10,000 loses $2,243 of income tax and $765 of FICA — $3,008, or 30.1%. The true cost is $1,550 of income tax and the same $765, or 23.2%. The gap between those two percentages, 6.9 points, is what a reader is looking at when a bonus feels halved. It is entirely timing.
The 2026 overtime deduction your paycheck does not show
For 2026 there is a third reason the withholding looks high, and this one is new. Qualified overtime compensation can be deducted — up to $12,500 on a single return, $25,000 joint — but only the FLSA premium counts: the half of time-and-a-half that exceeds the regular rate, not the whole overtime payment. The deduction is reduced above modified adjusted gross income of $150,000, or $300,000 on a joint return, and it expires after 2028.
It also does not reach your paycheck on its own. Publication 15 tells employers to use an updated Form W-4 if an employee wants the expected deduction reflected during the year, which means the default is to ignore it and settle in April. A worker whose overtime premium is $4,000 and whose marginal rate is 12% is therefore withholding $480 more than the year will owe, on top of everything above.
Three limits are worth knowing before counting on it. Only FLSA-required overtime qualifies, so an exempt employee has none however many hours the job takes; overtime paid at double time only counts the half portion; and the deduction requires a valid Social Security number, with a joint return if you are married. For 2026 the amount is also reported separately on the W-2, so the figure is on the form rather than reconstructed from pay stubs.
What to change, and what to leave alone
If the overtime deduction is the gap, the fix is Step 4(b) of the W-4: enter the deduction you expect, and the tables will withhold against a lower annual income. That is the mechanism the form provides, and it is the only one that adjusts for a deduction rather than an income.
If the gap is a bonus whose size you cannot predict, there is nothing to fix in advance. Adjusting Step 4(c) to chase a one-off payment makes every other check wrong. Let the 22% be wrong in whichever direction it lands and settle it on the return; if you expect it to under-withhold by more than $1,000 and would rather not owe in April, a single estimated payment does the same job without touching the W-4.
What is worth doing once is finding out which method your employer uses. A flat 22% on an overtime line, or a withholding rate that jumps across the whole check, tells you whether the annualisation described above is happening to you. The advanced calculator shows both totals for a bonus, and why two jobs withhold too little covers the related case where the shortfall is structural rather than seasonal.
What this page does not cover
- State withholding on supplemental pay. Several states use their own flat rate on bonuses, some of which exceed 22%; others apply the regular tables to the whole check. None of them is modelled here, and a state line can move the bonus’s total withholding by several points in either direction.
- Local tax. City and county wage taxes apply to bonuses on their own rules, and a few treat supplemental pay differently from regular wages.
- Retirement plan deductions. Whether a 401(k) percentage applies to a bonus depends on how the plan document defines compensation, which is a plan term rather than a tax rule.
- The penalty itself. This page explains why withholding and liability diverge; the underpayment computation is Form 2210’s, and it depends on when each payment arrived.
Frequently asked questions
Did my bonus push my salary into a higher bracket?
It pushed the top slice of your income there, and nothing below it. Brackets are marginal and never retroactive, so the bonus is taxed at the rate its own dollars reach, which is what the third column of the first table shows.
Why was a third of my overtime check withheld?
Three things stack. The check is annualised as if the overtime continued all year, which raises the rate on the whole check; FICA takes 7.65% of the overtime with no ceiling change; and any state withholding sits on top. Only the first is an estimate, and only the first comes back.
Should I ask for the bonus on a separate check?
It changes the withholding, not the tax. A separate check at 22% is closer to the truth for a salary between about $66,500 and $121,800 and further from it outside that range; a combined check annualises the bonus and usually over-withholds. Either way the difference is refunded or billed in April.
Sources
- IRS Publication 15 (2026) — the 22% flat rate on supplemental wages, the mandatory 37% above $1,000,000, and the instruction to use an updated Form W-4 so an expected overtime deduction reaches the paycheck
- 26 CFR 31.3402(g)-1 — overtime as supplemental wages, the employer’s option to treat it as regular wages, the aggregate procedure, and the conditions attached to the flat rate
- IRS Fact Sheet 2026-01 — qualified overtime compensation as the FLSA premium, the $12,500 / $25,000 cap, the phase-out, and separate reporting from 2026
- IRS Notice 2025-69 (PDF) — how the premium is identified when a statement reports overtime only in aggregate
- IRS Revenue Procedure 2025-32 (PDF) — the 2026 brackets used in every figure above
- SSA, contribution and benefit base — the $184,500 Social Security ceiling for 2026
Educational information only, not tax advice. Verify rates against the current IRS publications before relying on them.