Guide · Retirement · 2026
What a 401(k) contribution does to take-home pay in three states
A 6% deferral on a $75,000 salary moves $4,500 into the plan. Take-home pay falls by $3,510 in Texas, $3,287 in Illinois and $3,510 in Pennsylvania. Pennsylvania charges 3.07% on wages, and it loses exactly what Texas, which charges nothing, loses. That is not a rounding artefact: it is a different rule about when the dollar is taxed.
What a deferral changes, and what it cannot
Three tax bases sit under a paycheck, and a traditional 401(k) moves only one and a half of them.
- Federal income tax. The deferral comes out of wages before the tax is computed, so taxable wages fall by the amount deferred. This is the main saving, and it is worth the marginal rate rather than the average one.
- FICA. Untouched. Social Security and Medicare are computed on gross wages including the deferral, which is why a 401(k) never reduces the 7.65%. How FICA works explains the statutory reason.
- State income tax. This is where the three states part company. A state that starts from federal taxable income inherits the exclusion; a state that defines its own compensation base may not.
Run the numbers on a $75,000 salary, single, with a 6% deferral and nothing else on the return. Every line below is rounded to the dollar, and FICA is $5,738 in every column.
| Texas | Illinois | Pennsylvania | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Take-home, no deferral | $61,592 | $58,024 | $59,289 |
| Take-home, 6% deferral | $58,082 | $54,737 | $55,779 |
| Fall in take-home | $3,510 | $3,287 | $3,510 |
| Tax saved | $990 | $1,213 | $990 |
| Cost per $1 deferred | 78.0¢ | 73.0¢ | 78.0¢ |
The federal saving is $990 in all three, which is 22% of $4,500 — the bracket the salary sits in. Illinois adds $223 on top, and that is the whole of the difference: 4.95% of the deferral. Pennsylvania adds nothing.
Pennsylvania taxes the contribution, not the withdrawal
Pennsylvania does not accept the federal exclusion. Its Department of Revenue states the rule without hedging: contributions to a 401(k) “are considered part of the employee’s taxable compensation and are subject to withholding requirements”, and the treatment is the same whether the contribution is made inside or outside a cafeteria plan. The personal income tax guide puts the general principle first — employee contributions to any retirement plan are always taxable as compensation.
So the state line does not move when the deferral does. At $75,000 the tax is $2,303 either way, because the base is $75,000 either way. Only the federal $990 is saved, which is why Pennsylvania and Texas land on the same number despite tax rates of 3.07% and zero.
The other half of the rule is the reason it is not simply a penalty. Pennsylvania does not tax qualified distributions from an eligible plan once the recipient has retired at the plan’s retirement age. The state takes its 3.07% on the way in and nothing on the way out, which is the mirror image of the federal treatment and of most states.
Illinois takes it off both ends
Illinois begins with federal adjusted gross income, so a deferral that reduces federal AGI reduces the Illinois base by the same amount. The rate is 4.95% flat and the personal exemption is $2,925, which is why the tax on $75,000 is $3,568 rather than the $3,713 that a bare 4.95% suggests.
Then the second half: Illinois subtracts the federally taxed portion of distributions from qualified plans, including 401(k) plans, on the individual return. There is no age condition and no cap on that subtraction. A dollar deferred in Illinois is therefore outside the state base when it is earned and outside it again when it is withdrawn.
That is why the Illinois column shows the largest saving today. It is not a quirk of the exemption; it is a state that has decided not to tax retirement saving at either end, and the paycheck is where the first half of that decision shows up.
Three states, two ends of the same dollar
Put the two ends together and the three states stop looking like a ranking by tax rate:
| Per $1,000 deferred | When contributed | When withdrawn | Total state tax |
|---|---|---|---|
| Texas | $0 | $0 | $0 |
| Illinois | −$49.50 | $0 | −$49.50 |
| Pennsylvania | $30.70 | $0 | $30.70 |
Illinois shows a negative figure because the deferral removes the dollar from a base the state would otherwise tax, and never collects it later. Pennsylvania collects once, at a flat 3.07% that is among the lowest state rates in the country, and then stops. Texas has nothing to collect at either end.
Two cautions before treating that as advice. The Pennsylvania figure assumes a qualified distribution after retirement age; an early withdrawal is taxable, and the state’s cost-recovery rule treats early distributions as coming from already-taxed contributions first. And the Illinois subtraction depends on the distribution being included in federal AGI, so a Roth 401(k) — taxed on the way in, untaxed on the way out — does not produce the same arithmetic.
Where the limit bites
All of the above assumes the deferral stays under the 2026 elective deferral limit of $24,500, with a further $8,000 available from age 50 and $11,250 from 60 through 63. A percentage high enough to cross the limit stops saving tax at the limit: the excess is not wages deferred, it is wages that come back into the base.
A 20% deferral on $100,000 is $20,000 and stays inside the cap, so it saves the full marginal rate:
| $100,000 salary, 20% deferral | Texas | Illinois | Pennsylvania |
|---|---|---|---|
| Fall in take-home | $15,600 | $14,610 | $15,600 |
| Tax saved | $4,400 | $5,390 | $4,400 |
The federal saving is 22% again, and Illinois adds 4.95% of $20,000. At a salary where the marginal federal rate is 24%, the same deferral is worth two points more. That is the rule to carry away: a deferral is worth the rate on the last dollar it removes, which is the marginal rate and not the average one printed on the return.
What this page does not cover
- Local tax. Pennsylvania’s local earned income tax is levied on a compensation base that is generally the same one the state uses, so a local line usually ignores the deferral as well. It is not modelled in the figures above, and the rate depends on the municipality and school district rather than on the state.
- The employer match. It is not wages and never appears on the paycheck; it does change the value of the contribution, just not the arithmetic here.
- Other states. The three were chosen because their rules differ in kind, not because they are representative. A state that taxes contributions and also taxes distributions would show a worse total than any column above.
- Credits and other income. The saver’s credit, a second job, self-employment income and itemised deductions all move the federal line, and none is applied here.
The advanced calculator applies these rules to your own salary and state, including the states where the deferral does not reduce the state base. The state pages for Texas, Illinois and Pennsylvania carry the same schedules with their own sources.
Frequently asked questions
Does a 401(k) contribution reduce Social Security and Medicare tax?
No. FICA is computed on gross wages before the deferral, so the 7.65% is unchanged. Only income tax bases move, federal and — depending on the state — state.
Why is Illinois cheaper today than Texas, which has no income tax?
Because Texas has no state tax to save. Illinois charges 4.95%, so removing the deferral from its base is worth 4.95%; Texas cannot offer a deduction from a tax that is already zero. Over a lifetime both end at zero state tax on the deferred dollar — Illinois gives up 4.95% on the way in and takes nothing on the way out, Texas takes nothing either time. The difference is cash flow this year, not the total.
Does the deferral reduce take-home by less than it adds to the account?
Yes, by the tax saved. At the margin, $1 deferred costs 78 cents of take-home in Texas and Pennsylvania and 73 cents in Illinois. The 22 cents of federal tax not withheld is the subsidy, and it is a deferral rather than a forgiveness at the federal level.
Sources
- Pennsylvania Department of Revenue — 401(k) contributions are part of taxable compensation and subject to withholding, while distributions after retirement are not taxed
- PA Personal Income Tax Guide — Gross Compensation (PDF) — employee contributions to any retirement plan are always taxable as compensation; qualified retirement distributions are exempt
- Illinois Department of Revenue — the federally taxed portion of 401(k) distributions is not taxed by Illinois
- 35 ILCS 5/203 — Illinois net income begins with federal adjusted gross income, with the modifications listed
- IRS Publication 15 (2026) — elective deferrals remain subject to Social Security and Medicare tax
- IRS, 2026 retirement plan limits — the $24,500 elective deferral limit and the age-50 and age-60-to-63 catch-ups
- IRS Revenue Procedure 2025-32 (PDF) — the 2026 federal brackets used above
Educational information only, not tax advice. Verify rates against the current IRS publications before relying on them.